Ash wood substitute

Discuss all things Model T related.
Forum rules
If you need help logging in, or have question about how something works, use the Support forum located here Support Forum
Complete set of Forum Rules Forum Rules
User avatar

Topic author
BRENT in 10-uh-C
Posts: 229
Joined: Mon Jan 07, 2019 11:21 am
First Name: Brent
Last Name: Terry
* REQUIRED* Type and Year of Model Ts owned: 1909 Tourabout, 1914 Runabout, 1915 Touring, 1916 Speedster, 1925 Speedster, 1926 Hack
Location: Eastern Tennessee
MTFCA Number: 32295
Board Member Since: 1999
Contact:

Ash wood substitute

Post by BRENT in 10-uh-C » Thu Dec 08, 2022 9:34 am

I am really struggling with my local mill who I have used for the last 10-15 years to supply me with Ash hardwood for us to use in creating body infrastructure wood. Evidently the Ash Borer has pretty much eradicated standing Ash timber in my area, so I need to either travel to purchase 6/4 or 8/4 stock, -or find an affordable ($5.00 a board ft is NOT affordable) substitute species. Traveling to get it is not really that affordable either!! :o And, we typically use about 1,000 - 1,200 ft of timber a year e-wooding bodies.

Because I am getting down to about 300' left, I had him saw a Cherry log he had on the yard into 6/4 so at least I can start the air drying process, but I am definitely needing to get some stock purchased. Any suggestions on something alternate I should consider using that would be found in my area??

TIA!!

User avatar

Humblej
Posts: 1690
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2019 12:23 pm
First Name: Jeff
Last Name: Humble
* REQUIRED* Type and Year of Model Ts owned: 1926 Canadian built coupe, 1924 TT C-cab, survivor 1924 roadster
Location: Charlevoix, Mi
MTFCA Number: 28034
Board Member Since: 2006

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by Humblej » Thu Dec 08, 2022 10:00 am

Same issue with beetles in Michigan. For now, ash is still readily available and affordable. I get my ash lumber and planks from a local sawmill for less a board foot than pine at the home improvement store. If I had to find an alternative to ash for body wood I would use maple, hickory, birch, and white oak.

If you want to buy over 1000 bd ft at a time I think it would be worth your trouble to travel north and buy directly from a sawmill. If you want to travel to northern Michigan I can give you contact information for my local sawmill, but there should be many sawmills closer to you than Northern Michigan.


Rich P. Bingham
Posts: 1379
Joined: Sun Feb 13, 2022 11:24 am
First Name: Rich
Last Name: Bingham
Location: Blackfoot, Idaho
Board Member Since: 2015

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by Rich P. Bingham » Thu Dec 08, 2022 10:07 am

As you know, ash was always the gold standard in coach building for strength and machineability. The later Model T bodies were largely framed with poplar - adequately strong, and lighter. Cherry was favored by pattern makers, indicating it's working properties are acceptable, its strength for the application is questionable.

I believe at one time the U. S. Forest Service published data on commercial timbers indicating their useful properties. A quick search there might be useful to you. Keep us posted, please ! I'm always interested in what wood-workers find economical and useful ! You're lucky to be in a region where many species of hardwoods are readily available.
Get a horse !


Scott_Conger
Posts: 6431
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2019 11:18 am
First Name: Scott
Last Name: Conger
* REQUIRED* Type and Year of Model Ts owned: '13, '15, '19, '23
Location: Clark, WY
Board Member Since: 2005

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by Scott_Conger » Thu Dec 08, 2022 10:21 am

From a furniture making point of view, poplar is fabulous. It is traditionally used for the unseen, unfinished parts of furniture for the last 250 years in America. It cuts, joints, rabbets, like butter... has crisp sharp edges and endgrain is almost like long grain.

It does NOT hold up to weather and is a disaster if used on house trim, rotting in less than a few years unless scrupulously sealed and painted. Any water intrusion past the finish will start to work on it immediately. Thus, it would likely be fine for interior portions of a T, but I would never ever use it in any roof structure or anything that would potentially get wet and have a mating joint that could possibly stay wet for any length of time. Perhaps old growth poplar was more robust, I don't know.

Brent, you have a real dilemma there. The borer is slowly making its way across WY as well and my few ash trees will likely succumb when that happens. It is a real tragedy in multiple respects.

The floors in my cabin are hickory and are very tough and I wonder what board/ft cost is of that? Hickory is lousy to nail and prone to split, but you will be drilling and screwing...perhaps using a correct tapered drill with adjustable countersink from a woodworking supply to prep the joints for wood screws would be OK? I'd also think that the small nails for sheet metal would be less dreadful than what happens when you use larger nails.
Scott Conger

Tyranny under the guise of law is still Tyranny

NH Full Flow Float Valves
Obsolete carburetor parts manufactured


TXGOAT2
Posts: 6411
Joined: Sun Feb 14, 2021 10:08 pm
First Name: Pat
Last Name: McNallen
* REQUIRED* Type and Year of Model Ts owned: 1926-7 roadster
Location: Graham, Texas
MTFCA Number: 51486
Board Member Since: 2021

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by TXGOAT2 » Thu Dec 08, 2022 11:11 am

I had some heavy Poplar timber under some old engines. In spite of being oily, it rotted to fragments in 3-4 years. It might as well have been cardboard.


BobShirleyAtlantaTx
Posts: 361
Joined: Mon Jan 07, 2019 12:44 am
First Name: Bob
Last Name: Shirley
Location: Atlanta Tx
MTFCA Number: 29135

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by BobShirleyAtlantaTx » Thu Dec 08, 2022 12:44 pm

I built cabinets for years. Closed the shop around 2005. Had an inventory of red oak, white oak, maple, poplar, walnut, ash etc. The ash was the only lumber the bugs got into. Down in the stack they turned it into powder. Don’t think I could use ash in a car.


Jerry VanOoteghem
Posts: 2952
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2019 4:06 pm
First Name: Jerry
Last Name: Van
Location: S.E. Michigan
MTFCA Number: 24868

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by Jerry VanOoteghem » Thu Dec 08, 2022 1:13 pm

I'd go with white oak or hickory.


pron022020
Posts: 147
Joined: Thu Dec 23, 2021 1:43 pm
First Name: Tyler
Last Name: Prondzinski
* REQUIRED* Type and Year of Model Ts owned: 1927 Coupe
Location: Spring Grove, Illinois
Board Member Since: 2021

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by pron022020 » Thu Dec 08, 2022 2:32 pm

White oak is probably the next best thing, though I use Maple sometimes. At any rate, you need to spray it with a really good epoxy all around and that will negate ant future issues.

User avatar

Rich Eagle
Posts: 6796
Joined: Fri Jan 04, 2019 10:51 am
First Name: Richard
Last Name: Eagle
* REQUIRED* Type and Year of Model Ts owned: 1909 TR 1914 TR 1915 Rd 1920 Spdstr 1922 Coupe 1925 Tudor
Location: Idaho Falls, ID
MTFCA Number: 1219
Contact:

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by Rich Eagle » Thu Dec 08, 2022 3:55 pm

I remember Charley's comments from years ago.
Charley Shaver on Tuesday, October 07, 2014 - 10:52 pm:
"Eric! that's why I don't use ash or oak, I have about 300 bodies out there using sycamore.charley".
"Ford by the middle 20s was using a lot of yellow pine.charley".
FWIW!
Rich
http://www.mtfca.com/discus/messages/41 ... 1412557456
When did I do that?


tom_strickling
Posts: 388
Joined: Tue Jan 08, 2019 10:31 am
First Name: Tom
Last Name: Strickling
* REQUIRED* Type and Year of Model Ts owned: 11 Torpedo, 18 Touring, 21 TT Huckster, 24 snowmpbile Staude and Shaw tractor conversions, Model T powered sickel bar mower
Location: New Philadelphia Ohio

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by tom_strickling » Thu Dec 08, 2022 7:25 pm

Be careful with Sycamore. Some people a very allergic to its dust and chips. Both a skin and lung irritant to some folks.
“The trouble with retirement is that you never get a day off.” – Abe Lemons.

User avatar

Mark Nunn
Posts: 1105
Joined: Mon Jan 07, 2019 8:01 am
First Name: Mark
Last Name: Nunn
* REQUIRED* Type and Year of Model Ts owned: 1926 Runabout
Location: Bennington, NE
MTFCA Number: 50321
Board Member Since: 2017

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by Mark Nunn » Fri Dec 09, 2022 9:01 am

There are several types of mechanical properties that are published by the US Department of Agriculture. I have their wood handbook. Looking at modulus of rupture (breaking stress) and modulus of elasticity (bending), there are several hardwoods that are comparable to white ash. White ash is the strongest among ash varieties. Closest woods are:

Beech
Birch, yellow and sweet varieties
Hickory, all varieties including pecan, bitternut, shagbark, etc.
Black locust
Sugar maple
Northern red oak
Live oak (white)
Swamp chestnut
Swamp white oak
Black walnut


Rich P. Bingham
Posts: 1379
Joined: Sun Feb 13, 2022 11:24 am
First Name: Rich
Last Name: Bingham
Location: Blackfoot, Idaho
Board Member Since: 2015

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by Rich P. Bingham » Fri Dec 09, 2022 10:42 am

Thanks for that, Mark ! That's the handbook I had in mind when I posted in error that information was available from the forest service.

Everyone who works with wood should have that handbook ! (and I don't :oops:)

Besides breaking stress and elasticity, there are many other properties among species that may factor into their appropriateness for auto body framing. Machinability and paintability are two that manufacturers in the day would have considered especially, but may not be so prohibiting for the hobbyist restorer.
Get a horse !

User avatar

Mark Nunn
Posts: 1105
Joined: Mon Jan 07, 2019 8:01 am
First Name: Mark
Last Name: Nunn
* REQUIRED* Type and Year of Model Ts owned: 1926 Runabout
Location: Bennington, NE
MTFCA Number: 50321
Board Member Since: 2017

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by Mark Nunn » Fri Dec 09, 2022 1:23 pm

Rich P. Bingham wrote:
Fri Dec 09, 2022 10:42 am
Thanks for that, Mark ! That's the handbook I had in mind when I posted in error that information was available from the forest service.
Rich, you were not in error. Wood Handbook: Wood as an Engineered Material is published by:

Forest Products Laboratory
Forest Service
U.S. Department of Agriculture
Last edited by Mark Nunn on Fri Dec 09, 2022 8:27 pm, edited 1 time in total.


Rich P. Bingham
Posts: 1379
Joined: Sun Feb 13, 2022 11:24 am
First Name: Rich
Last Name: Bingham
Location: Blackfoot, Idaho
Board Member Since: 2015

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by Rich P. Bingham » Fri Dec 09, 2022 2:05 pm

Thanks for that kindness Mark. I need to see about getting a copy ! :D
Get a horse !


jab35
Posts: 892
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2019 12:28 pm
First Name: James
Last Name: Bartsch
* REQUIRED* Type and Year of Model Ts owned: '26 Coupe
Location: Dryden, NY 13053
MTFCA Number: 30615
MTFCA Life Member: YES

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by jab35 » Fri Dec 09, 2022 2:37 pm

If you can live with a pdf, it's right here:

https://www.fpl.fs.usda.gov/documnts/fp ... gtr282.pdf


Rich P. Bingham
Posts: 1379
Joined: Sun Feb 13, 2022 11:24 am
First Name: Rich
Last Name: Bingham
Location: Blackfoot, Idaho
Board Member Since: 2015

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by Rich P. Bingham » Fri Dec 09, 2022 2:50 pm

Even better ! Thanks James !!
Get a horse !


otrcman
Posts: 364
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2019 2:25 pm
First Name: Dick
Last Name: Fischer
* REQUIRED* Type and Year of Model Ts owned: 1912 Touring
Location: Arroyo Grande, CA

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by otrcman » Fri Dec 09, 2022 3:33 pm

Not mentioned yet is Alder. Alder is a hardwood which I have used for sand casting patterns for some time. It's very stable, easy machining, and really stands up to abuse by the foundry guys. I don't know about predatory insects, but I have had sand casting patterns that have been used on and off for 30 years. It's a fairly heavy wood and has always served well for me. When my Dad was re-wooding his Pierce Arrow years ago he used alder with good success.

P.S. It's relatively inexpensive as good quality hardwoods go.


J1MGOLDEN
Posts: 945
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2019 5:39 pm
First Name: James
Last Name: Golden
* REQUIRED* Type and Year of Model Ts owned: 1926 Model T Roadster
Location: Bowie, MD
MTFCA Number: 14294
MTFCI Number: 13562

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by J1MGOLDEN » Sat Dec 10, 2022 10:25 am

This is more information, but not a great copy.
Wood Specs Early 20th at 72.jpg
Wood Specs Early 20th at 72.jpg (75 KiB) Viewed 1693 times


Rich P. Bingham
Posts: 1379
Joined: Sun Feb 13, 2022 11:24 am
First Name: Rich
Last Name: Bingham
Location: Blackfoot, Idaho
Board Member Since: 2015

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by Rich P. Bingham » Sat Dec 10, 2022 11:57 am

otrcman wrote:
Fri Dec 09, 2022 3:33 pm
Not mentioned yet is Alder . . .
I have enjoyed working with alder. It machines and finishes beautifully. A drawback I encountered was its tendency to have strong internal stresses. That is, sawing a piece off of a nicely squared up plank would release internal stress to the point of binding the saw, requiring wedges to part the kerf and complete the cut; the piece that was parted off would be warped, and sometimes the parent flitch as well. This could be a function of where that particular timber was grown ? Perhaps not all alder lumber behaves that way ?

That said, dealing with this isn't insurmountable for the hobbyist, while it would be a serious drawback in production work. Once formed, items made remained stable enough in my experience, and it turns on a lathe like butter !

I question if it is strong enough for auto body framing, but it very well may be plenty strong for the application.
Get a horse !


MWalker
Posts: 474
Joined: Fri Jan 04, 2019 9:49 am
First Name: Mike
Last Name: Walker
* REQUIRED* Type and Year of Model Ts owned: 1916 Roadster Pickup
Location: NW Arkansas
MTFCA Number: 314
MTFCA Life Member: YES

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by MWalker » Sun Dec 11, 2022 12:24 pm

Alder is not available in 10-uh-C.


rickg
Posts: 76
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2019 2:44 pm
First Name: Richard
Last Name: Goelz
* REQUIRED* Type and Year of Model Ts owned: 1924 Fordor, 1926 Coupe, 1923 popcorn Truck
Location: Knoxville, Tn
MTFCA Number: 24965

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by rickg » Sun Dec 11, 2022 6:01 pm

Brent, if you haven't tried them try Jefferies Wood Works in Knoxville, they are actually in Seymour near Frank Henderson's, their number is865-573-5876 i bought a bunch of Ash several years ago from them and they have every kind of wood.

Rick


Loftfield
Posts: 223
Joined: Sun Jan 06, 2019 1:26 pm
First Name: Thomas
Last Name: Loftfield
* REQUIRED* Type and Year of Model Ts owned: 1912 Touring, 1912 Express Pick-up
Location: Brevard, NC, USA
MTFCA Number: 49876
MTFCI Number: 24725

Re: Ash wood substitute

Post by Loftfield » Mon Dec 12, 2022 7:24 am

About those bugs: powder-post beetles, termites, other wood borers, and carpenter bees as well will get into almost any hardwood. On interior wood, such as a car body that doesn't stay outside, they can be permanently and entirely safely eliminated by mixing sodium octoborate with polyethylene glycol (note, not ethylene glycol... car antifreeze). PEG is used as antifreeze in motorhome water systems, entirely safe. Mix at 50/50 then dilute 50/50 with water, brush on, leaves no evidence of its presence other than the little nasties rub against the sodium octoborate, then die when they lick themselves clean. The PEG protects against mold and fungus, a completely win/win approach. The wood can then be successfully stained, varnished, painted, whatever. This stuff can be bought ready-made in a good hardware store, I make my own, cheaper.

Poplar was given a bad name in some posts above. It was the preferred wood for barn siding across much of the US, doesn't rot if it can dry between rains. Again, you car isn't going to sit in the rain so poplar can be safely used for car body pieces. It works very easily, takes stain and varnish beautifully, can't go wrong. I did all the interior trim in my house from a tulip poplar that was taken down in the way of the construction. The color variation in the wood gives the interior an interesting look, not stupidly boring as does wood of a perfectly uniform coloration. Maybe an artistic streak is necessary to appreciate it, I don't know.

Post Reply Previous topicNext topic